MicroStrategy (MSTR) may be on the brink of a notable gamma squeeze scenario, driven by a large volume of deep in-the-money call options expiring in January 2025. With approximately 140,000 call options at play, and MSTR’s stock price hovering above $200, these options represent about 14 million shares or 7% of the company’s float. This situation might be compounded by high-strike call options for future dates, like the $350+ calls set for Dec 2025/January 2026. Let’s explore the incentives for exercising these options, the dynamics of a potential gamma squeeze, and whether a scenario similar to GameStop’s explosive squeeze might occur.

1. Incentives to Exercise Deep In-the-Money Options

Deep in-the-money (ITM) options are valuable due to their intrinsic worth. Investors holding such options have strong motivations to exercise them rather than simply sell, with factors ranging from intrinsic value to ownership advantages.

a. Maximizing Intrinsic Value

• Unlocking Immediate Value: Deep ITM calls hold substantial intrinsic value. For example, with a strike price of $100 and MSTR trading at $250, each option embodies $150 in intrinsic value. Exercising these options allows for an immediate conversion into shares, locking in this value without exposure to time decay or volatility.
• Avoiding Option Risks: Selling the options could be subject to market conditions, liquidity, or volatility shifts, making exercising a simpler and more straightforward strategy for realizing gains.

b. Ownership Benefits

• Voting Rights and Long-Term Gains: Exercising options converts them into actual shares, granting holders voting rights and potential dividends. This is particularly attractive to long-term investors seeking influence over the company’s direction and future growth.
• Strategic Control: Some investors may aim to consolidate their stake in MSTR, predicting a favorable long-term trajectory. Exercising deep ITM options offers them a clear path to solidifying their position without relying on the uncertainties of secondary markets.

c. Cost-Effective Execution

• Efficient Trading: Large quantities of deep ITM options might face liquidity constraints or higher transaction costs in secondary markets. By exercising, investors gain shares directly at a predictable cost, bypassing potential liquidity issues.

2. Gamma Squeeze Dynamics and Market Impact

A gamma squeeze scenario revolves around market makers being compelled to buy shares to hedge their positions as option prices fluctuate. This dynamic can create rapid and dramatic price escalations.

a. Mechanics of Gamma Hedging

• Gamma Hedging Explained: A gamma squeeze unfolds when market makers, who have sold call options, adjust their positions as the underlying stock price rises. To hedge, they buy shares, creating upward pressure on the stock price. This hedging action can lead to a self-reinforcing loop – rising prices trigger more hedging, which further drives up the price.
• Importance of Gamma: Gamma measures the sensitivity of an option’s delta to stock price changes. A high gamma indicates that even small price shifts necessitate considerable adjustments in hedging, prompting significant market maker activity.

b. Impact of 140,000 Deep In-the-Money Calls

• Massive Hedging Demand: With 140,000 deep ITM calls, market makers likely began hedging early, acquiring MSTR shares. If MSTR’s price rises further, more aggressive buying may occur as market makers adjust to limit their risk exposure.
• Market Sentiment and Confidence: Exercising these options would convert them into shares, signaling investor confidence. Such a move could create a positive feedback loop, drawing more buyers into the stock.

c. The Role of High-Strike Options (e.g., $450 for January 2026)

• Fueling Speculation: High-strike options introduce a speculative element. If $450 calls gain popularity, market makers would need to hedge by buying MSTR shares now, even if the current price is well below $450.
• Volatility and Premiums: Increased activity in high-strike options often elevates implied volatility, leading to higher option premiums. This volatility could entice more traders, escalating the pressure on market makers to hedge aggressively.

3. Steps to a Potential Price Squeeze (Parallels with GameStop)

A potential squeeze in MSTR could unfold in a three-phase cycle, echoing the GameStop narrative.

Step 1: Key Price Thresholds Trigger Hedging

• Above the $200 Mark: Consistent trading above $200 would force market makers who sold deep ITM calls to intensify their hedging by buying shares. This initial buying wave could set off a significant price increase.
• Speculative Traders Join In: As the stock climbs, the prospect of a squeeze might attract speculative traders – both institutional and retail – who hope to ride the momentum, further fueling the rally.

Step 2: Gamma Hedging Feedback Loop

• Self-Reinforcing Cycle: Continued price rises force market makers into a feedback loop, buying more shares to maintain their hedges. This cycle can drive rapid price increases as momentum traders and algorithmic trading systems jump on the trend.
• Retail and Social Media Influence: A notable factor in the GameStop squeeze was the role of social media. Should retail traders identify a squeeze opportunity in MSTR, the same dynamic could lead to increased buying from a broader audience, amplified by online platforms.

Step 3: Impact of Long-Dated High-Strike Options ($450 Calls for January 2026)

• Long-Term Speculative Bets: The presence of $450 call options allows for long-term speculative plays. If these options gain traction, market makers will hedge, irrespective of the current stock price, creating additional buying pressure.
• Volatility Surge: High-strike options can drive up implied volatility, attracting more interest in the stock and adding another layer to the feedback loop, pushing MSTR even higher.

4. Could MSTR Experience a GameStop-Like Squeeze?

While every gamma squeeze has its unique elements, parallels with GameStop exist, but the extent of MSTR’s squeeze potential hinges on several factors.

a. Conditions for a Squeeze

• Speculative Momentum: A gamma squeeze in MSTR could transition to a broader short squeeze if upward pressure from gamma hedging triggers panic among short sellers. This would drive a rapid cycle of buying as shorts rush to cover their positions.
• Retail Influence: The participation of retail investors, spurred by social media, can be a decisive factor. If a perceived squeeze opportunity goes viral, trading volumes and volatility could surge, creating the conditions for an explosive rally.

b. Exponential Price Movements

• Rapid Price Escalation: If a gamma squeeze takes hold, MSTR’s price could soar beyond intrinsic values in a short timeframe, driven by speculative fervor and hedging mechanics. Such a move would mirror the meteoric price increases seen in GameStop’s saga, underscoring the potential for extreme volatility.

5. Investor Strategies: Navigating Deep In-the-Money Calls in Different Account Types

Holding deep in-the-money (ITM) call options opens up strategic pathways, but these strategies differ significantly based on the type of investment account. The potential for a gamma squeeze in MicroStrategy (MSTR) brings these considerations to the forefront. Let’s examine investor strategies in two scenarios: holding deep ITM calls in regular trading accounts versus Individual Retirement Accounts (IRAs). Additionally, we’ll explore creative ways to maximize gains while managing risks.

Scenario 1: Holding Deep ITM Calls in Regular Taxable Accounts

In a regular trading account, profits from exercising or selling deep ITM call options are subject to taxes. Investors need to navigate capital gains taxes, which can significantly impact net returns.

Tax Implications and Strategies

• Short-Term vs. Long-Term Gains: Gains from the sale or exercise of options are taxed as either short-term or long-term capital gains. Selling or exercising deep ITM options held for less than a year results in short-term gains, taxed at ordinary income tax rates (which could be 10% to 37% in the U.S.). Holding these options for over a year qualifies them for long-term capital gains rates (0%, 15%, or 20%).
• Exercise to Delay Tax Liability: Exercising deep ITM options, instead of selling them, allows the investor to convert them into shares, effectively deferring the taxable event until the shares are sold. This deferral can be advantageous if you anticipate long-term appreciation.
• Strategic Sales: Investors can stagger the sale of shares acquired through exercised options to manage tax liabilities over multiple years, potentially keeping them within lower tax brackets.
• Using Tax-Loss Harvesting: If an investor holds other securities at a loss in their portfolio, selling these at a loss can offset gains from selling deep ITM options. This tax-loss harvesting strategy helps reduce the overall taxable gain for the year.

Creative Strategies in Taxable Accounts

1. Covered Calls: After exercising ITM calls and owning the shares, investors can sell covered calls against their stock holdings. This allows for additional premium income, which can hedge potential downturns and generate cash flow while holding the shares.
2. Rolling Options: Investors may consider rolling their deep ITM calls to a later expiration date. This involves selling the current deep ITM call and buying a similar call with a longer expiration. This can extend the timeframe while potentially capturing additional appreciation without an immediate taxable event.
3. Cash-Secured Puts: If an investor is interested in acquiring more shares or selling some of the deep ITM calls, they can sell cash-secured puts at a lower strike price. This strategy can allow them to enter new positions at potentially favorable prices or generate premium income.
4. Margin Loans for Tax Efficiency: If exercising the options and converting to shares, investors could take a margin loan against their brokerage account instead of selling shares to avoid triggering a taxable event. This provides liquidity while deferring capital gains taxes.

Scenario 2: Holding Deep ITM Calls in IRA Accounts

In IRA accounts, investment activities have different tax implications since these accounts are either tax-deferred (Traditional IRA) or tax-exempt (Roth IRA). Here’s how strategies can shift within the tax-advantaged environment of an IRA.

Tax Advantages and Strategies

• No Immediate Tax Consequences: Exercising deep ITM options within an IRA does not trigger an immediate tax event. In a Traditional IRA, taxes are deferred until withdrawal, while in a Roth IRA, all gains and distributions are tax-free (assuming the account has been held for at least five years and the investor is over 59½).
• Flexibility for Aggressive Strategies: The tax shelter of an IRA allows for more aggressive options strategies without worrying about annual tax implications. Gains from selling or exercising deep ITM options in an IRA are not subject to capital gains tax, allowing for reinvestment of the full profit.
• Timing is Key: Investors holding deep ITM options in an IRA can exercise or roll them without triggering tax liabilities. They can also continue reinvesting gains without restrictions, maximizing compounding potential.

Creative Strategies in IRA Accounts

1. Aggressive Rolling Strategies: Investors can roll deep ITM calls into higher-strike options with future expiration dates, like the $450 calls for January 2026, without tax consequences. This allows for potential continued upside participation with limited additional cost.
2. Synthetic Long Positions: In an IRA, investors can create synthetic long positions by buying deep ITM calls and selling deep out-of-the-money puts. This mimics stock ownership without directly holding the shares, allowing for leverage without using margin.
3. Leveraging Cash-Protected Trades: If the IRA is well-funded, consider leveraging cash-covered options strategies (like cash-secured puts) to hedge positions or generate additional income.
4. Conversion Between Traditional and Roth IRA: If a deep ITM call position has grown substantially, converting a Traditional IRA to a Roth IRA may make sense, even though it triggers tax liability on the conversion amount. This could be advantageous for younger investors expecting long-term gains, allowing all future appreciation to occur tax-free.

6. Creative Ways to Benefit from a Potential Gamma Squeeze

The gamma squeeze scenario in MSTR offers investors various ways to capitalize on price momentum and navigate market volatility. Here’s a list of detailed strategies that can be adapted based on market conditions:

1. Profit from Implied Volatility Surges

• Buying Volatility: Consider purchasing options (calls or straddles) when implied volatility is low, in anticipation of a rise due to a potential gamma squeeze. If volatility increases as expected, option premiums can appreciate significantly, even if the stock price doesn’t move dramatically.
• Straddles and Strangles: A straddle involves buying both a call and put at the same strike price, betting on a volatility spike. A strangle uses different strikes, offering a cheaper but riskier volatility play. These strategies can profit from a sharp move in either direction if a squeeze unfolds.

2. Capitalize on the Rising Stock Price

• Pyramid into Positions: If the squeeze scenario materializes, consider pyramiding into a position- starting small and adding incrementally as the stock rises. This reduces initial risk while allowing you to scale up if the squeeze accelerates.
• Take Partial Profits: During a squeeze, volatility can lead to rapid price spikes. Taking partial profits during these periods can lock in gains while retaining exposure to further upside.
• Using a Trailing Stop: Implementing trailing stops on shares acquired through exercising options can help capture profits while allowing for upside participation. A trailing stop automatically adjusts as the price rises, protecting gains during volatility.

3. Utilize Advanced Option Strategies

• Vertical Call Spreads: Buying a call spread (purchasing a lower strike call and selling a higher strike call) can limit risk while benefiting from a targeted price increase. This strategy is particularly effective in a rising market driven by gamma hedging.
• Iron Condors or Iron Butterflies: If volatility spikes excessively, consider using neutral strategies like iron condors or iron butterflies, which profit from high premium levels and a stable stock price. These strategies can capitalize on inflated options premiums without directional risk.

4. Enhance Yield with Income Strategies

• Sell High-Strike Covered Calls: If holding shares, selling covered calls at inflated strike prices (like the $450 January 2026 calls) can generate significant premium income during high volatility periods. This can reduce cost basis or provide income if the options expire worthless.
• Covered Call Write & Roll: If the stock price rises, roll covered calls up and out to higher strikes or later expirations, capturing premium without sacrificing upside potential. This tactic is valuable during prolonged periods of elevated volatility.

Conclusion

MicroStrategy’s deep ITM calls, combined with potential high-strike options, create fertile ground for a possible gamma squeeze. The conditions could align for a rapid price surge as market makers engage in aggressive hedging, and speculative traders jump on the momentum. If this squeeze gains traction, MSTR’s stock might witness sharp, exponential price movements reminiscent of GameStop’s rise. Keeping an eye on options open interest, market maker activity, and speculative interest will be crucial for anticipating MSTR’s future trajectory.

Investors holding deep ITM call options in MSTR can navigate this potential gamma squeeze with a range of strategies tailored to their account types. Tax considerations play a crucial role in regular accounts, while IRAs offer greater flexibility for aggressive and creative maneuvers. In both cases, understanding market mechanics, volatility, and hedging strategies can lead to substantial gains in a rapidly evolving scenario.

The potential for a gamma squeeze in MSTR highlights the dynamic and sometimes unpredictable nature of financial markets, where a blend of technical factors, speculation, and investor psychology can drive significant price movements.

📲 Schedule a call to talk to an expert

Disclaimer: The content provided in this article is for informational and educational purposes only and does not constitute financial, investment, or tax advice. Investing in stocks, options, or any other financial instruments involves risk, including the potential loss of principal. Strategies discussed, including those related to a potential gamma squeeze, may not be suitable for all investors. Tax implications can vary based on individual circumstances, and it is recommended to consult with a qualified financial advisor, tax professional, or accountant before making any investment decisions. Past performance is not indicative of future results, and all investment decisions should be based on your own research and risk tolerance.

Also read, The Future of Capital Markets: Michael Saylor’s MicroStrategy Bitcoin Vision

Join Crypto Exponentials Newsletter. Gain Access To $10k/Month Challenge!

Access Blockchain Educational Resources 👇

Crypto Exponentials’ education section offers resources to help users understand the complex world of cryptocurrency and blockchain technology. It includes a range of content focused on decentralized finance (DeFi), blockchain fundamentals, crypto trading, NFTs, and emerging trends. The platform emphasizes practical knowledge and strategies for beginners and advanced users, aiming to empower individuals to make informed decisions in the rapidly evolving crypto market. For more details, you can visit the CryptoExponentials Education Page

👉 Check out here